Become a Better You: Reflections on Joel Osteen’s Latest Book

By Michael S. Horton

It was a pleasant afternoon a few years ago in my back yard, writing an article, when Modern Reformation executive editor Eric Landry informed me that he had scheduled me for an interview on Joel Osteen for “Dateline NBC.” Knowing nothing about Mr. Osteen or his message at that time, I declined-with no effect whatsoever on Landry’s force of will. “Here’s the book: Your Best Life Now. So you’d better get reading!”

Little did I know then that Osteen already was a phenomenon and would only become a greater one as months wore on. In retrospect, I am glad to have had the opportunity to talk to so many people who are confused about the message that Osteen preaches and that seems to pervade so much of ordinary American preaching and spirituality in our day.

A CBS “60 Minutes” interview sparked more recent requests for comment concerning Osteen’s new book, Becoming a Better You: 7 Keys to Improving Your Life Every Day. I took it with me on a recent flight and I offer the following reflections.

Heavier Emphasis on the Prosperity Gospel
Under the Library of Congress identification, this book is classified as “1. Self-actualization (Psychology)-Religious Aspects-Christianity.” Even the Library of Congress seems to know what sort of message this represents. “You can be better,” Osteen invites. “The question is: ‘How? What must I do to become a better me?’ In my first book, Your Best Life Now, I presented seven steps to living at your full potential.” But with Becoming a Better You, he wants to go a little deeper. “I’m hoping to help you look inside yourself and discover the priceless seeds of greatness that God has placed within you. In this book, I will reveal to you seven keys that you can use to unlock those seeds of greatness, allowing them to burst forth in an abundantly blessed life.”

Remember, God has put in you everything you need to live a victorious life. Now, it’s up to you to draw it out….What does it mean to become a better you? First, you understand that God wants you to become all that He created you to be. Second, it is imperative that you realize that God will do His part, but you must do your part as well. To become a better you, you must:
1. Keep pressing forward.
2. Be positive toward yourself.
3. Develop better relationships.
4. Form better habits.
5. Embrace the place where you are.
6. Develop your inner life.
7. Stay passionate about life.1
The theme is “coming up higher.” From beginning to end, Osteen addresses his vast readership as though each person is “a child of the Most High God.”

God has breathed His life into you. He planned seeds of greatness in you. You have everything you need to fulfill your God-given destiny….It’s all in you. You are full of potential. But you have to do your part and start tapping into it…You have the seed of Almighty God on the inside of you…We have to believe that we have what it takes.2
It is indeed true that there are appeals to the Bible scattered throughout this book. However, in nearly every case a verse is either torn from its context and turned into a “fortune-cookie” kind of promise that one can name-and-claim for oneself or it is actually misquoted to serve Osteen’s point. For example, we read that when God confronted Adam and Eve after their sin, “He said, ‘Adam, who told you that you were naked?’ In other words, ‘Who told you that something was wrong with you?’ God immediately knew the enemy had been talking to them. God is saying to you today, ‘Who told you that you don’t have what it takes to succeed?’”3 Where, in the passage he refers to (Genesis 3:11), God asks Adam this question in order to convict him of his sin, Osteen makes it sound as if it were Satan who told Adam that he had failed the test.

As in his earlier book, Osteen here never speaks of sin as falling short of God’s glory, but of falling short of God’s best for your life. In fact, Osteen’s attachment to the prosperity gospel is even more explicit in Become a Better You. Just as Kenneth Copeland, Benny Hinn, and other “faith teachers” speak of believers as “little gods” who share God’s nature, Osteen has an entire chapter devoted to “The Power of Your Bloodline.” “You have the DNA of Almighty God.”4 It’s “what’s in you” that is divine seed, he says.5 It is not that God has imputed Christ’s righteousness to us and adopted us as his children. We are not saved by an external and alien righteousness, but by an internal and essential righteousness that belongs to us simply by virtue of our being created in his image. Therefore, throughout the book Osteen can address all of his readers as semi-divine without any reference to faith in Christ.

As if the fall never happened, Osteen writes, “He has programmed you with everything you need for victory. That’s why every day you can say things like, ‘I have what it takes. I am more than a conqueror. I am intelligent; I am talented. I am successful; I am attractive; I am an overcomer.”6

Where Paul, in Galatians 3:29 argues that the inheritance of eternal life comes through the promise (i.e., Christ) rather than by the law, Osteen again lifts a single verse out of its context as a promise of temporal prosperity:

I love the Scripture that says, ‘If we belong to Christ, we are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise.’ That means that we can all experience the blessings of Abraham. If you study Abraham’s record, you’ll discover that he was prosperous, healthy, and lived a long, productive life. Even though he didn’t always make the best choices, he enjoyed God’s blessings and favor.7
This is a clear example of how Osteen turns even the most obvious references to Christ (as the fulfillment of Old Testament prophecy) into timeless examples of what can happen to us if we name and claim our blessings. He does not interpret Scripture; he uses it as a book of quotations to serve his own prosperity message.

The book is shot through with the lingo of the prosperity gospel: we are to “declare” God’s blessing, “speak” prosperity, and “prophesy” health, wealth, and happiness into our lives. All of this creates the impression that God has set everything up for our victory, but it is up to us to actually plug into the power-source and create our blessings by following the proper principles and procedures.

So in spite of the supernatural rhetoric, at the end of the day it all sounds deistic: God has set everything up, with the laws of prosperity in place, and now the ball is in our court. Following a well-worn path of “victorious life” teachers, Osteen speaks of “tapping into” the eternal realm. In this way, even religion becomes a species of technology: by knowing the right principles, formulas and steps, prosperity, blessing, and favor can be yours here and now. Once again, the Gnostic brand of spirituality is readily apparent.

He wants us to have a little heaven on earth, right where we are…[Y]ou can accomplish your dreams before you go to heaven! How can you do that? By tapping into God’s power inside of you…Please understand that those are all things from which you have already been set free. But here’s the catch: If you don’t appreciate and take advantage of your freedom, if you don’t get your thoughts, your words, your attitudes going in the right direction, it won’t do you any good. You may be sitting back waiting on God to do something supernatural in your life, but the truth is, God is waiting on you. You must rise up in your authority, have a little backbone and determination, and say, ‘I am not going to live my life in mediocrity, bound by addictions, negative and defeated.8
I’m all for positive thinking-as long as we don’t call it the gospel. I come from a long line of Wild West pioneers and can identify with Osteen’s commendation of his parents as a major source of an optimistic outlook. The problem is when we blindly ignore the reality of our condition before God. Whatever good things there may be about me, none of them commend me before God’s righteous judgment.

Moving beyond positive thinking, Osteen embraces “positive confession,” the prosperity doctrine that says if you not only believe for something but declare that it is already yours, the desired blessing will become true. God may be the source of this blessing in an ultimate sense, since he set things up, but whether we actually receive God’s favor and blessings depends entirely on our attitude, action, and obedience.

Osteen devotes a chapter to “Making Your Words Work for You.” “Every day, we should make positive declarations over our lives,” he writes. “We should say things such as, ‘I am blessed. I am prosperous. I am healthy. I am talented. I am creative. I am wise.’”9 Joe’s wife could not carry her pregnancies to full term, so Joe changed his name to the fuller name, “Joseph,” meaning “God Will Add.” “Several months after Joseph began believing his name,” Osteen tells us, “his wife became pregnant again. And for the first time in ten years, she carried the child full term, and gave birth to a healthy baby boy…With our words, we can prophesy our own future.”10 “Something supernatural happens when we speak it out. That’s how we give life to our faith…Declare it by faith and use your words to change that situation.”11

This means that whatever God has done to make all of this possible, the victory that we are actually able to achieve and the blessings that we are actually able to receive depend on our effort. So in a chapter titled, “Have Confidence in Yourself,” Osteen repeats his mantra, again misquoting the Bible:

The Scripture says, ‘Our faith is made effectual when we acknowledge everything good in us.’ Think about this: Our faith is not effective when we acknowledge all our hurts and pains. It’s not effective when we stay focused on our shortcomings or our weaknesses. Our faith is most effective when we acknowledge the good things that are in us.12
The closest thing that I have been able to find to the wording cited by Osteen is Paul’s statement in 2 Corinthians 12:9: “But he [Jesus] said to me, ‘My grace is sufficient for you, for power is perfected in weakness.’ Therefore, I will most gladly boast all the more about my weaknesses, so that Christ’s power may reside in me.”

Of course, if this is the verse that Osteen has in mind, it says exactly the opposite of Osteen’s paraphrase. In fact, it is part of a larger explanation of why Paul, in contrast to the “super-apostles” who were leading the Corinthians astray with their “smooth talk and flattery,” would “not boast about myself, except of my weaknesses.” In fact, Paul says that God gave him a “thorn in the flesh, so that I would not exalt myself” (2 Cor. 12:5-10). In times of weakness, distress, and difficulty, Paul says, where we lose our self-confidence to handle our situation before God, we are actually in the best position for God to show his power.

Redefining the Christian Message
In the only clear reference to trusting in Christ that I came across in this book, Osteen still feels compelled to include us as the object of faith: “When we believe in God’s Son, Jesus Christ, and believe in ourselves, that’s when our faith comes alive. When we believe we have what it takes, we focus on our possibilities” (emphasis added).13

Even when the concepts of sin and redemption are employed, they are redefined. Sin is not a condition of rebellion that we inherit from Adam, but diseases, poverty, and bad attitudes that we inherit from our family line. In the Bible, a “curse” has its proper place in the context of the covenant. For example, in Ancient Near Eastern treaties, which form the pattern of covenantal thinking employed in the Bible, an emperor would bring down his judgment on a rebellious tribe or nation under his rule. This sanction would be called a “curse.” However, in the prosperity gospel, “curse” is more nearly related to the world of magic-the way we usually speak of curses in our culture today. So where the curses that God invokes upon humanity as a result of Adam’s sin in the garden are a judicial sentence, Osteen speaks of “generational curses” that have no obvious reference to divine judgment. You may have inherited your grandmother’s genes, which included the curse of diabetes. However, “You need to put your foot down and say, ‘Grandmother may have had it [diabetes]. Mother may have had it. But as for me and my house, we’re redeemed from diabetes. I’m going to live under the blessing and not the curse.”14

A doctor named Vanessa refused to accept her joint disease and she was eventually delivered of it, Osteen relates. “This type of blessing is for believers, not doubters.”15 His father had high blood-pressure, but kept saying, “Joel, I will never have a stroke.” “He was saying that by faith because he struggled with high blood pressure his entire life. He would say, ‘I’ll never be incapacitated. I’ll never come to the place where I cannot preach.’ And true to his faith, my father preached just eleven days before he went to be with the Lord.”16 It would not be surprising, then, if such teaching led a sincere follower to conclude that a failure to be healed or to become financially prosperous was the result of one’s own disobedience.

If I am diagnosed with Grandma’s diabetes, am I a doubter rather than a believer? “The Bible calls it an iniquity,” Osteen writes.17 It is a curse from generation to generation “until somebody rises up and puts a stop to it. For example, when Adam and Eve disobeyed God, that decision didn’t just affect them; it affected their children. Do you know who the first murderer was in the Bible?…The iniquity kept getting passed down through generations of Cain’s offspring.”18

Therefore, in the place of the Christian doctrine of original sin (viz., the whole human race being guilty and corrupt in Adam) is the notion of “iniquity” as a genetic trait that someone in one’s family tree allowed into the bloodstream. Quite literally, Osteen believes, the curse is in the blood, just as each person has God’s DNA. The generational curse is lifted by our obedience, when someone in the family line finally “takes authority” over it. Absent is any reference to sin as a condition of being opposed to God, guilty before God, and corrupt in heart, mind, soul and will. The ethical character of sin as both a condition and specific actions of transgressing or failing to conform to God’s law is exchanged for a magical conception.

At the same time, our victory over generational curses is entirely manageable. We can overcome the “iniquity” that has been passed down to us: “God has given you free will. You can choose to change…People who have been abused are the most likely to become abusers. Why is that? It is not because they want to. They know how destructive it is. It’s because that negative spirit keeps being passed down. Thank God, you and I can do something about it.”19

Just as sin is redefined as a failure to attain prosperity in all areas of life, redemption is now understood as freedom from pain, illness, poverty, as well as the bad attitudes and negative habits that our parents or grandparents passed on to us.

Think of it like this: Each of us has a spiritual bank account. By the way we live, we are either storing up equity or storing up iniquity. Equity would be anything good: our integrity, our determination, our godliness. That’s storing up blessings. On the other hand, iniquity includes our bad habits, addictions, selfishness, lack of discipline.20
“Your faithfulness is noticed in heaven. You are storing up equity for both yourself and generations to come.”21 A more thorough-going works-righteousness is difficult to conceive:
Get up every day and give it your best effort. If you will do that, not only will you rise higher and accomplish more, but God has promised that your seed, your family line for up to a thousand generations, is going to have the blessings and the favor of God-all because of the life that you’ve lived.22
So we see once again that Osteen has not abandoned the “legalism” of previous generations. If anything, he intensifies it, but his followers do not recognize the tightening noose or the mounting burden because he makes it sound so easy. It is not easy, however, to be told that one’s health, wealth, and happiness-as well as one’s victory over sin and death-depend on the extent of our determination and effort. A weak view of sin fails to bring us to the end of our rope; instead, it encourages us to try just a little bit harder to save ourselves. It’s easy. Really.

Therefore, Osteen advises, we need to stop listening to accusing voices. Any voice that accuses, convicts, or condemns is the voice of Satan, according to Osteen. He nowhere suggests that this may be the voice of the Holy Spirit, showing us our guilt and helplessness before God’s law in order to drive us to Christ. We are not morally bankrupt before God. Sin is reduced to certain attitudes and actions that we can put a stop to whenever we want. Therefore, we do not need a one-sided rescue operation outside of us. The seed of goodness is still within us, waiting to explode if we will just nurture it.

One wonders what Osteen would do with passages such as the following: “Our righteousness is like filthy rags” (Is. 64:6); “There is no one righteous; there is no one who does good, no not even one” (Rom. 3:10). Where Jeremiah says “The heart is more deceitful than anything else” (Jer. 17:9), Osteen says that his confidence before God is in the righteousness of his own heart: “I may not have a perfect performance, but I know my heart is right….Similarly, as long as you’re doing your best and desire to do what’s right according to God’s Word, you can be assured God is pleased with you. Certainly, He wants you to improve, but He knows that we all have weaknesses.” Sin is reduced to “human foibles and imperfections” that “poke through our idealism….”23 “As long as we’re doing our best, we don’t have to live condemned even when we make mistakes or fail.”24

Although he does mention God’s forgiveness and mercy, this divine grace is not understood as something that comes at the price of Christ’s atoning sacrifice. It is not because God has reconciled us to himself through the death of his Son, but because he is an indulgent father who let’s bygones be bygones, that we can receive his forgiveness and move on.

Even Paul’s experience in Romans 7 is reduced to a “nobody’s perfect” kind of speech. “The Apostle Paul once said, ‘The things I know I should do, I don’t. The things I know I shouldn’t do, I end up doing.’ Even this great man of God who wrote half the New Testament struggled in this regard. That tells me God does not disqualify me merely because I don’t perform perfectly, 100 percent of the time. I wish I did, and I’m constantly striving to do better. I don’t do wrong on purpose, but like anyone else, I too have weaknesses.”25 However, this trivializes Paul’s travail in that chapter, where he laments not simply his failure to score a perfect 100, but his failure-even as a believer-to gain victory over his sins. This does not lead him to say, in effect, Let’s brush ourselves off and do our best anyway. He does not say, “Nobody’s perfect. At least my heart is right,” but rather, “Oh, wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death?” Only this deep anguish over the depravity of his own heart can lead him to look not within but outside of himself: “I think God through Jesus Christ our Lord!” (Rom. 7:24-25).

There is no clear sense in Osteen’s message that God has forgiven and justified us because even though we stand condemned according to the law we are declared holy by Christ’s imputed righteousness. Rather, God just ignores our guilt and focuses on the good things he apparently sees in us. “However, God does not focus on what’s wrong with you. He focuses on what’s right with you. He’s not looking at all your faults and weaknesses.”26 Again, the “good news” according to Osteen is that God does not judge us according to his law (the 100 percent rule), but looks at our heart and sees something decent in all of us. “I am bold enough to believe that I am a friend of Almighty God, and that he is smiling down on me right now. I’ve accepted the fact that I don’t perform perfectly all the time, but I know my heart is right. To the best of my ability, I’m doing what pleases Him.”27 His forgiveness is due not to Christ’s having borne our debts, so that there is no more guilt to be judged, but to God’s decision to overlook our faults: “He chooses not to remember your mistakes, your sins, your failures.”28 “God approves you unconditionally, just as you are.” Again, no mention of Christ. “Frankly, it’s not because of what you have or haven’t done; God loves you because of who you are and because of who he is. God is love.”29

We do have to be careful here. Of course, God is love. He is also righteous, holy, and just. God’s love and justice are fully realized together-not by overwhelming these other attributes with his love, but by sending his own Son to live a perfect life in our place, suffer judgment in our place, and be raised for our justification. By setting the justice aside, Osteen actually obscures the glory of the cross and greatness of God’s grace.

Instead of acknowledging that we are still sinners, though justified and renewed in Christ, we need to confess that we are “no longer poor old sinners, we are sons and daughters of the Most High God.”30 Osteen confuses the bad preaching of the law as scolding with the proper preaching of the law as driving us out of ourselves to Christ. “Sometimes religion tries to beat people down and make them feel bad about themselves. ‘You’ve done this and you failed here, and you didn’t treat this person right, and you didn’t raise your kids as well as you should have.’…’Why don’t you lighten up and give yourself a break?…If you’ve made mistakes, just say ‘God, I’m sorry; I repent. Help me to do better next time.’”31

Instead of pointing us to Christ, where God’s record-keeping was justly satisfied and the court transcription was nailed to the cross (Col. 2:14), Osteen just gets rid of the idea of any negative record. God is certainly recording our good works, but not our sins. If this is the case, however, why do we need Christ at all? We certainly do not need him to live a perfect life in our place, but do we even need him to offer himself to death in our place if the only record-keeping that counts is the good things that we have done? Osteen adds,

He’s not keeping a list of your shortcomings. God is not looking at everything you’ve done wrong over your entire life or your disobedience last week. He’s looking at what you’re doing right. He’s looking at the fact that you have made a conscious decision to be better, to live right, and to trust Him. He is pleased that you are kind and courteous to people.32

Far from the struggle of Paul in Romans 7, Osteen makes it sound as if we can manage the sin-problem by our own positive outlook. “If you want to sin, you can sin. I sin all I want to,” he says. “The good news is that I don’t want to…Stop dwelling on everything that’s wrong with you and taking an inventory of what you’re not. The Scripture says in Hebrews, ‘To look away from everything that distracts.’”33 Once again, Osteen misquotes the Bible to make his point. Hebrews 12:1-2 actually reads, “Therefore, since we also have such a large cloud of witnesses surrounding us, let us lay aside every weight and the sin that so easily ensnares us, and run with endurance the race that lies before us, keeping our eyes on Jesus, the source and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy that lay before him endured the cross, despising its shame, and sat down at the right hand of God’s throne.” In other words, the counsel is to look away from ourselves-both our sins and our good works-and not let anything distract us from Christ. Yet Osteen’s entire message represents a distraction from Christ. Who needs Christ if this is the gospel: “You’re not perfect, but you are trying to live better, and God looks at your heart. He sees the inside, and He is changing you little by little”?34

Once again, Osteen’s message-though perhaps a bit more explicitly oriented toward the prosperity gospel than most-is not all that different from the general drift of a lot of popular religion and spirituality that pervades even our own evangelical circles today. The focus is on us rather than on God, on our happiness apart from God’s holiness, on our “ascending higher” by moral effort rather than on our being receivers of God’s saving work in Jesus Christ. “I know, too, even when my plans don’t work out, even when things don’t go my way, because I am honoring God and striving to keep the right attitude, God will make it up to me.”35

The Good News? God’s Keeping Score!
Having exchanged the gospel of Christ’s doing, dying and rising, for a pep talk for our doing, declaring, and rising, Osteen can say, “The world does not need to hear another sermon nearly as much as it needs to see one.” 36 Now we are the “good news.” And here is the gospel according to Joel Osteen:

God is keeping the records. He sees every act of kindness you show. He sees every time you are good to somebody. He hears every encouraging word you speak. God has seen all the times you went out of your way to help somebody who never said thank you. Your good deeds do not go unnoticed by Almighty God.37
But once we are placed back under the law for righteousness, on what basis can Osteen claim that God only counts the good works? Is there a single passage in the Bible that separates God’s record-keeping in this way, so that our good works can bring God’s favor and blessing but our sins do not count at all? If we are going to inherit God’s promises by the “righteousness that is by the law,” then Osteen’s pleasant outlook hardly seems justified.

Make no mistake about it, behind all of the smiles, there is a thorough-going religion of works-righteousness: “God’s plan for each of our lives is that we continually rise to new levels. But how high we go in life, and how much of God’s favor and blessings we experience, will be directly related to how well we follow His directions.”38 God “is waiting for your obedience so He can release more of His favor and blessings in your life…My question to you is: How high do you want to rise? Do you want to continue to increase? Do you want to see more of God’s blessings and favor? If so, the higher we go, the more disciplined we must be; the quicker we must obey.”39 “You don’t get the grace unless you step out. You have to make the first move. God will see that step of faith and He’ll give you supernatural strength to help you overcome any obstacles standing in the way of doing the right thing…Remember: How high you go in life will be directly related to how obedient your are.”40

And if anyone has any questions about whether this plan is workable, Osteen offers himself as an example:

I know I’m not perfect, but I also know this: My conscience is clear before God. I know that I’m doing my best to please Him. That’s why I can sleep well at night. That’s why I can lie down in peace. That’s why I have a smile on my face. Friend, keep your conscience tender, and you will discover that life keeps getting better and better.41
By contrast, Jesus and his apostles taught that the searching judgment of God through his law brings conviction, pricking my conscience that I have fallen short of God’s glory. My conscience does not render a positive verdict in God’s courtroom. The only reason I can sleep well at night is that even though my heart is still filled with corruption and even though I am not doing my best to please him, I have in heaven at the Father’s right hand the beloved Son who has not only done his best for himself, but has fulfilled all righteousness for me in my place.

Just as Joel Osteen has decided for himself the message that he will preach, he has also tailored his own vocation. In interviews, he has said that he is not called to explain the Scriptures or expound doctrine. In this book he adds, “I’m not called to explain every minute facet of Scripture or to expound on deep theological doctrines or disputes that don’t touch where real people live. My gifting is to encourage, to challenge, and to inspire.”42 Ambassadors do not get to choose what they say. As ministers of the gospel, our “gifting” is to “preach the whole counsel of God” (Ac 20:27).

Have we actually come to a place in Evangelicalism where we will listen to people who clearly tell us that they are not called to explain and expound the Scriptures? A number of responses I have received after being interviewed regarding Osteen’s message criticized me for failing to show a united front against the real enemies: the liberals. However, it is unclear to me how Osteen’s message displays any higher regard for the authority and basic teaching of the Scriptures. Once upon a time, conservative Protestants imagined that theological liberalism was the greatest threat to authentic Christianity in our time. With liberalism almost completely irrelevant as an active school or movement, Osteen’s success confirms my suspicions that evangelicalism itself is becoming a more serious obstacle to evangelical faith and practice today.

——————————————————————————–

NOTES:

Joel Osteen, Becoming a Better You: 7 Keys to Improving Your Life Every Day (New York: Free Press, 2007), . [Back to text]
2Ibid., 5. [Back to text]
3Ibid., 9. [Back to text]
4Ibid., 34. [Back to text]
5Ibid., 35. [Back to text]
6Ibid., 37. [Back to text]
7Ibid., 40. [Back to text]
8Ibid., 41. [Back to text]
9Ibid., 109. [Back to text]
10Ibid., 114. [Back to text]
11Ibid., 115. [Back to text]
12Ibid., 129. [Back to text]
13Ibid., 130. [Back to text]
14Ibid., 45. [Back to text]
15Ibid., 46. [Back to text]
16Ibid., 334. [Back to text]
17Ibid., 50. [Back to text]
18Ibid. [Back to text]
19Ibid., 56. [Back to text]
20Ibid., 59. [Back to text]
21Ibid., 67. [Back to text]
22Ibid., 69. [Back to text]
23Ibid., 86. [Back to text]
24Ibid., 86-87. [Back to text]
25Ibid., 87. [Back to text]
26Ibid., 89. [Back to text]
27Ibid., 91. [Back to text]
28Ibid., 91. [Back to text]
29Ibid., 101. [Back to text]
30Ibid., 102. [Back to text]
31Ibid., 39. [Back to text]
32Ibid., 103. [Back to text]
33Ibid., 104. [Back to text]
34Ibid., 105. [Back to text]
35Ibid., 218. [Back to text]
36Ibid., 186. [Back to text]
37Ibid. [Back to text]
38Ibid., 301. [Back to text]
39Ibid., 302. [Back to text]
40Ibid., 308. [Back to text]

——————————————————————————–

The Rev. Dr. Horton is the J. Gresham Machen professor of systematic theology and apologetics at Westminster Seminary California, the host of the nationally syndicated broadcast of The White Horse Inn radio program, editor-in-chief of Modern Reformation magazine, and a minister in the United Reformed Churches of North America.

Dr. Horton is also the author/editor of more than fifteen books, including: Putting Amazing Back Into Grace; Made in America; A Better Way: Rediscovering the Drama of God Centered Worship; God of Promise: Introducing Covenant Theology; and Too Good To Be True: Finding Hope in a World of Hype. He received his Ph.D. from Wycliffe Hall, Oxford, and the University of Coventry, and resides in Escondido, California, with his wife Lisa and their four children.

15 Responses to “Become a Better You: Reflections on Joel Osteen’s Latest Book”

  1. There are so many things to which one can comment on here. I am not a follower, nor do I regularly tune in to Joel Osteen’s programs. However, I have listened to a few of his presentations to know his presentations are mentally sound and spiritually strong.

    His willingness to affirm the giftedness of his audience is no different than Jesus pulling the children to him and applauding their youthful energy and passion for wanting to live the good life.

    While the strength of your beliefs are in what you have read about what Jesus may or may not have done, the truth is, you as well as I are faced not with living our lives back in 30 B.C. You and I are faced with meeting the demands for love in the year 2007. And, right now…I believe you will agree…you are loved and loved right now unconditionally by God.

    You did not earn the giftedness you have. You did not have to earn your blessings. The life before you was granted without request or fee. This life we live with The Father always close and near to us is a blessing given to us freely without suffering or stains of blood upon a cross. The grand scheme of things, from the very beginning, was that you should enjoy the life you have and share that life with others so they might want the good life always.

    All Osteen is saying is “What YOU do with that giftedness is totally up to you.” You can be delusional and ignore your magnificense…But, don’t be suprised when the end result would be days feeling without gifts or blessing. Because you ignore the gifts does not mean they have disappeared. Or because you have nailed a man to a cross does not mean they have disappeared. There is always room to be loved in the heart of the God you have known for years.

    As hard as it is for you to hear, read, or watch happen, the opportunity to enjoy the true peace and happiness of what God offers is ALWAYS ready for your use. It is for this very reason Jesus dies on the cross; to prove death has no power over the granduer of The Father’s love. The same would be true of you, me, our mothers, or fathers.

    If you want to speak about there being a great Satan out there who fights against every thing you try to accomplish that is good …you’re free to do so. BUT, do not complain when your days are full of conflict, suffering, and depressing thoughts and bad moments. Conflict is what you have focused on…Conflict is what you will to experience. And that, as you have come to experience over the years….is okay! God is still gonna love ya! And, your gifts are still there for your use. What a deal!

    Does this mean its okay to beat the crap out of somebody. No, its delusional to THINK a lie is a good thing. And, that is our problem with what we hear Osteen say. It sounds different, so we think it just can’t be real or true. So, we retreat to what we have been taught.

    Osteen’s perspective is to choose not to give “sin” aire time. He wants ONLY to focus on his message he feels compelled to explain. Osteen’s perspective is to choose to focus on what we CAN control in the life we have been given freely by God to enjoy in the Kingdom of God. Sin, being the lie that it is, is an illusion that always morphs into something else. This is why living a life of lies is so unstable. BUT, what IS real are the gifts and blessings we have been granted FREELY.

    In the end, where you presently find yourself spiritually is okay. Perhaps your message is different for the ones you are offered to lead. Lead them well with love as your guide. Eventually, like you, we all will discover a truly great relationship is waiting for us with a God who apparently loves us without err.

    Thanks for allowing me to share this with you.

    AngllHugnU2
    Author of IM with God
    http://www.booklocker.com/books/2980.html

  2. The problem comes with Mr. Osteen in this:

    The True Gospel (Good News) is one that has bad news too. When you omit the bad news, you omit the True Gospel. When Mr. Osteen is not willing to stand on the issues that Christ is the only way to the Father:
    John 14:6
    Jesus said to him, “I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.

    then He omits the True Gospel.

    If Mr. Osteen is not willing to talk about sin and repentance:
    Mark 1:14-15
    Now after John was arrested, Jesus came into Galilee, proclaiming the gospel of God, 15 and saying, “The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand; repent and believe in the gospel.”

    then he is not preaching the Gospel that Jesus preached.

    If Mr. Osteen is not willing to preach what Jesus preached, namely Himself being crucified for SIN:

    1 Corinthians 1:22-23
    For Jews demand signs and Greeks seek wisdom, 23 but we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles…

    then he does not preach what the apostle Paul preached.

    If Mr. Osteen is not willing to call people to repentance and the forgiveness of SIN:

    Acts 2:28-41
    And Peter said to them, “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. 39 For the promise is for you and for your children and for all who are far off, everyone whom the Lord our God calls to himself.” 40 And with many other words he bore witness and continued to exhort them, saying, “Save yourselves from this crooked generation.” 41 So those who received his word were baptized, and there were added that day about three thousand souls.

    then he does not preach what the apostle Peter preached.

    When Mr. Osteen states that man is basically good, or there is a “Champion in You!,” he is mistaken:

    Mark 10:17-18
    And as he was setting out on his journey, a man ran up and knelt before him and asked him, “Good Teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal life?” 18 And Jesus said to him, “Why do you call me good? No one is good except God alone.

    When Mr. Osteen states that we can think rightly when we change ourselves, he contradicts the apostle Paul:

    Romans 3:10-18
    “None is righteous, no, not one;
    11 no one understands;
    no one seeks for God.
    12 All have turned aside; together they have become worthless;
    no one does good,
    not even one.”
    13 “Their throat is an open grave;
    they use their tongues to deceive.”
    “The venom of asps is under their lips.”
    14 “Their mouth is full of curses and bitterness.”
    15 “Their feet are swift to shed blood;
    16 in their paths are ruin and misery,
    17 and the way of peace they have not known.”
    18 “There is no fear of God before their eyes.”

    When Mr. Osteen says that man is not condemned before God and is in right standing without repenting and believing in the only Son of God:

    John 3:18
    Whoever believes in him is not condemned, but whoever does not believe is condemned already, because he has not believed in the name of the only Son of God.

    then he is contradicting the apostle John.

    And if Mr. Osteen states that there is no sin in man, which is what he insinuates when he states there is a champion in you:

    1 John 1:5-10
    This is the message we have heard from him and proclaim to you, that God is light, and in him is no darkness at all. 6 If we say we have fellowship with him while we walk in darkness, we lie and do not practice the truth. 7 But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus his Son cleanses us from all sin. 8 If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. 9 If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. 10 If we say we have not sinned, we make him a liar, and his word is not in us.

    If Mr. Osteen keeps preaching this false message of false hope = you are good, you can have hope with no message of repentance and forgiveness in Christ, you can be successful materially, you can have the best God has to offer without the offer of Jesus as Savior from sin, death and Hell:

    Jude 3-4
    Beloved, although I was very eager to write to you about our common salvation, I found it necessary to write appealing to you to contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints. 4 For certain people have crept in unnoticed who long ago were designated for this condemnation, ungodly people, who pervert the grace of our God into sensuality and deny our only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ.

    and

    2 Corithians 11:2-4
    For I feel a divine jealousy for you, since I betrothed you to one husband, to present you as a pure virgin to Christ. 3 But I am afraid that as the serpent deceived Eve by his cunning, your thoughts will be led astray from a sincere and pure devotion to Christ. 4 For if someone comes and proclaims another Jesus than the one we proclaimed, or if you receive a different spirit from the one you received, or if you accept a different gospel from the one you accepted, you put up with it readily enough.

    and

    Galatians 1:8
    But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed.

    and

    James 3:1
    Not many of you should become teachers, my brothers, for you know that we who teach will be judged with greater strictness.

    then WOE to him, for he will be judged by God.

    My prayer for Mr. Osteen:
    Our Father, who is in Heaven. You alone are holy. You alone are ever present. You alone have the power and the ability to change men’s hearts. Father, our hearts are desperately wicked. Our flesh wants to boast in ourselves and put ourselves on a pedastel. We tend to think of ourselves higher than we should. Lord, our culture preaches self-esteem rather than dying to self. Our culture teaches us to lay treasures here on earth and live the best life right now rather than seeing the future that Christ, Your Son, is coming again and that He will being the sword. Father, forgive this culture and forgive me for not being faithful. Lord, I lift Mr. Osteen up to you. I give this man to change. I pray that he will see the truth in Your Divine Revelation and repent and believe on the only begotten Son of God. I pray that he will count the cost of following after Christ. Lord, please help him. Most of us know of his gentle sincerity. I pray that he will submit to Your Lordship and find peace in Your Truth, the Gospel of Jesus Christ.

    Amen.

  3. Once again, there are so many issues raised in the last comment. Ultimately, the message I am hearing from the comment is “Why is Osteen encouraging people to touch their greatness, their goodness, their talent, their gifts? And, my only answer to this is “Why not!”

    In the long list of examples provided above each is an essential part of the litany of reasons for why people are convinced they are incapable of touching, owning, and participating in the valuable life they have been given freely by God. The reasons given above are excellent reasons why most people can not act in the way Jesus would.

    Most everybody is faced with the hardship and challenges of correcting the mistakes, great or small, in which they find theirselves. We all know we tend to ignore our greatness when we find ourselves lost in the fog of the lies we create to ignore the blessings we’ve been given freely by God in the first place. You words above are perfect expressions of “I simply can not believe God loves us that easily to bless us with so much regardless of what we do differently!”

    Osteen has a simple message he feels called to deliver. Your’s may differ. And, that’s okay! Osteen’s message is “You have the capacity to recognize true happiness in your life by grabbing onto the valuable gifts and blessing bestowed upon you unconditionally by a God that loves you always. Go use them! It’s okay to feel blessed!”

    Let’s face it! Look all around. There is, everywhere you look, constant impressions and images of how a person should act, behave, dress, or even pray. Each seems to be perfect in their presentation. BUT, inherent in these images is the message “If this is not how you act, behave, dress or even pray your life is worthless.” Nothing is always farthest from truth. And, the above is best described as nothing!

    Osteen is simply implying that a person is far greater than the illusion of perfection in the above mentioned messages. The reality of living a happy life is all in a matter of perspective. And, that perspective is attitudinal. And, because Osteen’s message is about attitude is very susceptible to attack.

    Encouragement will always urge the subject of its message to move forward toward achievement. You should know this from the mentor’s who loved you enough to encourage you to touch your own divine granted blessings and gifts. Encouragement will always ignore attack and choose to move the subject of its message to feel success.

    Osteen knows mistakes will be made along life’s journey to meet The Father in eternity. He simply chooses to encourage his audience with what is possible. Why? Because people want to know that what they sense they have in talent and gifts from a God that loves them is real. Osteen is simply saying, “Yes! Your blessings are real! Now go have fun using them!”

    Ultimately, we all just need to calm down, watch the fog of our mistakes fade and notice how truly close The Father is in our lives.

    Thank you for allowing me to share this.

    AngllHugnU2
    Author of IM with God
    http://www.booklocker.com/books/2980.html

  4. You said:
    “Why is Osteen encouraging people to touch their greatness, their goodness, their talent, their gifts? And, my only answer to this is “Why not!”

    Scripture says:
    “None is righteous, no, not one;” (Romans 3:10)

    “Their throat is an open grave;” (Romans 3:13)
    - This last verse in particular nullifies that there is anything great in us. It states that something at the bottom of our throat, namely our heart, is dead.

    “all our righteous deeds are like a polluted garment” (Isaiah 64:6) (or filthy rags)
    - This verse nullifies that our talents are of any worth or value in and of themselves.

    “And Jesus said to him, “Why do you call me good? No one is good except God alone.” (Mark 10:18)

    and

    “If you then, who are evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will the heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to those who ask him!” (Luke 11:13)

    These verses nullifies any goodness within us or about us.

    Are we valued? Yes. But the reality is God deals with SIN! We are polluted. We are wretched as the apostle Paul says. Our hearts are wicked as Jeremiah says: The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately sick; who can understand it? (eremiah 17:9)

    When you promote a “hope” without contemplating the reality of things as God has deemed, then you promote no hope at all. It is like standing in the middle of a burning house with no hope of escape and saying… “Oh. Just think postively and the abundant life will come. You know, be encouraged for you are great.” Then the walls of Cancer, death, car wrecks, etc. set in and reality strikes… you are now before the Lord and He says: “Depart from me, I never knew you.” And the one who thought he was saved and doing God’s will and promoting His Divine thoughts from Scripture says, “But Lord, did I not cast out devils and heal people and preach your Word and sing in the Church choir and encourage people in Your Name.” And He turns and says: “You did things that were not in my name… You strayed from the Word of God… You were not born again… You rejected the Gospel of my Son and now I reject you.”

    This is scary sir. A way SEEMS right to a man, but it leads to death.

    We must promote the True Gospel of Jesus Christ… not a Gospel that promotes man and makes God his waterboy… not a Gospel that states man is good and there is a champion in him… but states that “The natural person does not accept the things of the Spirit of God, for they are folly to him, and he is not able to understand them because they are spiritually discerned.” (1 Corinthians 2:14)

    We either reject the entertainment and the pop-psychology and turn to the True Gospel, or we perish. This is the reality of the Bible, God’s holy and Divine Word. Believe it or do not. It is our responsibility to believe Christ crucified.

    In Christ, RAP

  5. “Are we valued? Yes. But the reality is God deals with SIN! We are polluted. We are wretched as the apostle Paul says. Our hearts are wicked as Jeremiah says: The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately sick; who can understand it? (eremiah 17:9)”

    The passion you possess to ignore the richness of the umcompromisingly wonderful creation that you are is obvious. BUT, do not project onto others the disgust you have for being so blessed. I do realize it feels better in the mud when others are pulled into it with you. Eventually, those you pull into the ditch will only become equally disgusted with the life they lead or hate you for convincing them of such a dire illusion.

    After having said that, I guess, in the end if in the mud is where you want to reside…then in the mud of sin you will play until such time when you come to realize life is good and full of wonders. Its the same place in which the Prodigal Son believed he would find true peace. BUT, feeding the pigs just didn’t cut it. He would eventually realize the gifts and blessings of the life his father had provided were okay to possess. And so, to his father he returned.

    I, along with the rest of the blessed, wait patiently for your return so that we might celebrate Life as it should be in Peace surrounded by the goodness of God.

    Peace

    AngllHugnU2
    Author of IM with God
    http://www.booklocker.com/books/2980.html

  6. RACHEAL RATEMO Says:

    Joel Osteen’s sermon and books inspires and motivates me.

  7. That is the purpose and meaning of each and everyone of us. To share what we know to gain knowledge of how great we are in the eyes of the God who expresses us to life…..Perfectly!

  8. “The passion you possess to ignore the richness of the umcompromisingly wonderful creation that you are is obvious.”

    We are wonderfully and beautifully created, Amen. (Psalm 139)

    We are blessed. Amen. (Matthew 5-7)

    I do not ignore these things. My point is that the way to be blessed is to be in Christ Jesus, the Son of the Living God. When we think that God’s blessings are deserved it ceases to be grace. When we believe that God’s grace is ours for the taking, we misunderstand grace in God. Grace in God is given. But it is given to His children. Who are the children of God? It is not simply everyone or anyone.

    It is ONLY for those who believe in Jesus: 9 The true light, which enlightens everyone, was coming into the world. 10 He was in the world, and the world was made through him, yet the world did not know him. 11 He came to his own, and his own people did not receive him. 12 But to all who did receive him, who believed in his name, he gave the right to become children of God, 13 who were born, not of blood nor of the will of the flesh nor of the will of man, but of God. (John 1:9-13)

    We are fallen people. It has nothing to do with whether or not we are blessed. It has everything to do with whether or not Jesus knows us as His own. It has everything to do with salvation, whether we are poor and oppressed or rich and kings. If we do not have Christ, we do not have the Father who is in Heaven.

    The only way to know God is to know His Son, Jesus. If you have Him then you are blessed. The way to know Him is to know who you are before God. Jesus called us evil. Paul called us natural and wretched. John called us sinners.

    When we acknowledge who we are before the almighty as sinners, receive His precious gift of salvation for the forgiveness of sin and then lead a life of faithfulness, persevering to the end… then we are able to sing a shout of praise before the Almighty. If we do not confess our sins before the Lord… and if we do not forgive others God refuses to forgive us. (Matthew 6)

    It is very important that your eternal life be secured in the true Gospel of God, which is repentance and belief in His only begotten Son Jesus. And when there is no message of sin in the pulpit and only a message of living your best life now, then there is no Gospel… only motivational, pop-psychology.

    “I do realize it feels better in the mud when others are pulled into it with you. Eventually, those you pull into the ditch will only become equally disgusted with the life they lead or hate you for convincing them of such a dire illusion.”

    Tell me: Would my message bring me persecution in 1st century Rome or would Mr. Osteen’s? I think the Roman emperor would say, “Sure, think better about yourself, but I am the son of god, not this Jesus. Repent? Repent for what. Sin… the only sin is to not sacrifice to me. So I am fine with your message Mr. Osteen. Talk about happy feelings, positive thoughts, a better attitude… but you better not talk about Jesus, Sin, and eternal life through this Gospel found in the writings of Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Paul, Peter and Jude.”

    “if in the mud is where you want to reside…then in the mud of sin you will play until such time when you come to realize life is good and full of wonders. Its the same place in which the Prodigal Son believed he would find true peace.”

    I have salvation through repentance of Sin… I reside in the mud no longer. I have put on the Lord Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of sins.

    By the way… the Prodigal returned in repentance and the Father received Him. Do you think the Father will receive you on your terms or His? Do not be arrogant and think you can believe and do what you want to do. Do not be proud and despise the Gospel of God. You must repent of SIN and believe in the Son of God for forgiveness.

    “Joel Osteen’s sermon and books inspires and motivates me.”

    What do they inspire you to do? Do you have the ability to do any good? What does it motivate you to do? Are you able on your own and through your works to merit the pleasures of God without repentance and belief in Christ? The Bible is a different message all together. The Gospel is offensive for it demands repentance and belief. In this culture, pretty words and feel-good messages are all we can handle. When the Bible speaks, we say, “No, that is not right.” I will hold it up and say some words about it and then put it down and pepper our messages with quotations and Scripture verses, but never teach what it truly says about God and His Son.

    “That is the purpose and meaning of each and everyone of us. To share what we know to gain knowledge of how great we are in the eyes of the God who expresses us to life…..Perfectly!”

    I will simply let your words speak for themselves.
    Our purpose according to Scripture and many confessions of faith through the centuries (now abandoned by so many) is to glorify God. An example:

    Westminster Confession of faith, Question #1: What is the chief end of man? To glorify God by enjoying Him forever.

    Are you man-centered or God-centered? Your purpose mentioned demonstrates that you think of man very highly… too highly. Are you worshipping the created thing or the Creator? (Romans 1) It is not us who are great, but God who is great and beautiful and worthy and awesome and lovely and holy and enumerable more adjectives. You are a sinner in need of a Savior.

    Let me tell you what God thinks of us:
    1. He hates and loves us at the same time… He loves the unloveable.
    - Proverbs 6:16-19 – There are six things that the Lord hates,
    seven that are an abomination to him:
    17 haughty eyes, a lying tongue,
    and hands that shed innocent blood,
    18 a heart that devises wicked plans,
    feet that make haste to run to evil,
    19 a false witness who breathes out lies,
    and one who sows discord among brothers.

    Have you ever been in this category? I have.

    2. God has condemned man to death.
    - 2 Thessalonians 2 – The coming of the lawless one is by the activity of Satan with all power and false signs and wonders, 10 and with all wicked deception for those who are perishing, because they refused to love the truth and so be saved. 11 Therefore God sends them a strong delusion, so that they may believe what is false, 12 in order that all may be condemned who did not believe the truth but had pleasure in unrighteousness.
    (ALL ARE UNRIGHTEOUS)

    3. God has provided a way out because of His unconditional love.
    - John 3:16 – For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son that if you believe in Him you will have eternal life.

    4. In believing and repentance you will have eternal life and know the Son of God.
    - John 17:3 – And this is eternal life, that they know you the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom you have sent.

    I expect people to hate this message. It is promised by God that it will be:
    Luke 6:22-23 – “Blessed are you when people hate you and when they exclude you and revile you and spurn your name as evil, on account of the Son of Man! 23 Rejoice in that day, and leap for joy, for behold, your reward is great in heaven; for so their fathers did to the prophets.”

    And what did the prophets preach to make the nation of Israel hate them: Repentance of Sin!

    Luke 21:17 – You will be hated by all for my name’s sake.

    John 7:7 – 7 The world cannot hate you, but it hates me because I testify about it that its works are evil.
    (In this message, it is not me you hate, but Jesus)

    John 15:18-25 – 18 “If the world hates you, know that it has hated me before it hated you. 19 If you were of the world, the world would love you as its own; but because you are not of the world, but I chose you out of the world, therefore the world hates you. 20 Remember the word that I said to you: ‘A servant is not greater than his master.’ If they persecuted me, they will also persecute you. If they kept my word, they will also keep yours. 21 But all these things they will do to you on account of my name, because they do not know him who sent me. 22 If I had not come and spoken to them, they would not have been guilty of sin, but now they have no excuse for their sin. 23 Whoever hates me hates my Father also. 24 If I had not done among them the works that no one else did, they would not be guilty of sin, but now they have seen and hated both me and my Father. 25 But the word that is written in their Law must be fulfilled: ‘They hated me without a cause.’

    How does God express to us life perfectly? In His Son, Jesus the Messiah. Believe in Him, repent of your sins and you will have eternal life. Amen.

    In Christ, RAP

  9. “We are wonderfully and beautifully created, Amen. (Psalm 139)…I do not ignore these things. (But, these blessings are) ONLY for those who believe in Jesus. We are fallen people.”

    These thoughts are your reality. These thoughts are nothing new. You are not alone in this endeavor of belief. Because these thoughts actually are, for the vast majority of us the way we see ourselves.

    We can not imagine our lives being simply blessed. Each and everyone of us wants there to be something wrong with the idea of having greatness and beauty as something inherent in our creation by God. So, in order to maintain the belief in Murphy’s Law, (something is bound to go wrong) we begin to project our confidence in being weak onto those with whom we live.

    To project onto others a failed view of Self prohibits us from ever truly enjoying the depth of beauty and magnificense of what God offers to us in everyone person we would meet. The outcome, in this regard, will always be one of fear with invisible walls of prejudgments forming impersonal barriers of dispair.

    For example, while I do believe you are deeply passionate about the bible and what it offers as defense for your message, the impression I get from you is one where you feel co-dependent upon the bible speaking for you. It seems you have yet to notice the depth of your own God-given blessing of intelligence.

    On one thing I do believe you and I can agree, “God breathed life into you and I.” Set aside all of what biblical supports you rely upon for a moment and consider the enormous suggestion of spiritual intimacy that conveys to how close you are to God right now. There can never be anything, no object, no president, no preacher, no prophet, no action you can do to change the very act of God breathing life into you.

    Now you might think some mistake you may have participated in would make you unworthy of such an intimate gift as the breath of God. But, that thought of lack is unfounded. Why? Because the gift of God’s breath comes to you freely and unconditionally.

    Believe or not, like it or not, you are loved well beyond any one thing you try to do to make God’s love stop. The very reason Jesus visits with us is to help us to realize, recognize, understand, appreciate and ultimately love the close spiritual and intimate relationship we enjoy with The Father. And, His effort to explain that very fact to us would carry their way well beyond the cross, well beyond the grave and into your very hands.

    It is in the understanding of this aspect of the Life of Jesus where we notice the simple message of Osteen blooms. All Osteen is suggesting to his core audience is “to grab onto the valuable assets of the true blessings of what The Father has handed down to you freely. Use them for the benefit of helping yourself grow spiritually, personally, and economically.”

    In conclusion, it is okay to be blessed by God. If Jesus had not ever come to this world, we would still be blessed by God. We still would be faced, as we are today, with a decision to use our gifts with God by our side. Or think we are using our gifts all by our lonesome for our own stated means. The death and resurrection of Jesus only underscores the enormous depth of The Father’s commitment to love us always.

    Thanks for allowing me to share all of this with you.

    AngllHugnU2
    Author of IM with God
    http://www.booklocker.com/books/2980.html

  10. “We can not imagine our lives being simply blessed. Each and everyone of us wants there to be something wrong with the idea of having greatness and beauty as something inherent in our creation by God. So, in order to maintain the belief in Murphy’s Law, (something is bound to go wrong) we begin to project our confidence in being weak onto those with whom we live.”

    You are blessed when you receive Christ as your Lord and Savior, knowing that in Heaven your citizenship resides.

    We are fearfully and wonderfully made. My reality is in line with Scripture. I do not like to talk about “my” reality, but God’s reality of the way things are. We either run away from God’s reality because it is too harsh or we run to it and embrace it and accept the way things truly are. If man is so “great” why do I not see the divorce rate going down, murder going away, steacling, cheating, plundering, etc. No, man is not great, God is Great.

    I do not subscribe to Murphy’s Law, I subscribe to God’s Law which states we must repent and believe in Christ for the forgiveness of Sin.

    In our weakness we are made strong. Not in our greatness. In Christ alone are we made strong in God and His righteousness.

    - Romans 8:1-9 – There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus. 2 For the law of the Spirit of life has set you free in Christ Jesus from the law of sin and death. 3 For God has done what the law, weakened by the flesh, could not do. By sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh and for sin, he condemned sin in the flesh, 4 in order that the righteous requirement of the law might be fulfilled in us, who walk not according to the flesh but according to the Spirit. 5 For those who live according to the flesh set their minds on the things of the flesh, but those who live according to the Spirit set their minds on the things of the Spirit. 6 For to set the mind on the flesh is death, but to set the mind on the Spirit is life and peace. 7 For the mind that is set on the flesh is hostile to God, for it does not submit to God’s law; indeed, it cannot. 8 Those who are in the flesh cannot please God. 9 You, however, are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, if in fact the Spirit of God dwells in you. Anyone who does not have the Spirit of Christ does not belong to him.

    “To project onto others a failed view of Self prohibits us from ever truly enjoying the depth of beauty and magnificense of what God offers to us in everyone person we would meet. The outcome, in this regard, will always be one of fear with invisible walls of prejudgments forming impersonal barriers of dispair.”

    Projection is a psychological term… rather I use Biblical terms such as “persuade.” I try to persuade others, not by my power, but by the power of the Holy Spirit. I don’t try to talk eloquently, lest the power of the Holy Spirit be robbed from Him. I simply map out the view of man that is found in Scripture. To accuse me of “projection” is wrong headed and argumentum ad hominem.

    Fear is not necessarily a bad thing. Look at what Jesus says:
    - Matthew 10:28 – 28 And do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather fear him who can destroy both soul and body in hell.

    And what David says:
    - Psalm 147:11 – “but the Lord takes pleasure in those who fear him, in those who hope in his steadfast love.”

    And what Solomon says:
    - Proverbs 1:7 – “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of knowledge; fools despise wisdom and instruction.”

    It seems to me from Scripture, fear is a great thing when directed properly. Not irrational fear, but a healthy fear for God who controls all things.

    “For example, while I do believe you are deeply passionate about the bible and what it offers as defense for your message, the impression I get from you is one where you feel co-dependent upon the bible speaking for you. It seems you have yet to notice the depth of your own God-given blessing of intelligence.”

    The Word of God is sharper than a two-edged sword that cuts through bone and marrow straight into the soul of Man. Yes, I believe the Bible for all of my message. My intelligence comes from God and I am blessed to meditate on His Divine Word, day and night so that I may be prosperous according to Him, not according to worldly treasures or vain pursuits or pretty words cloaked in Christian terminology. I am all about renewing my mind according to His thoughts which are found not within me, but within His Word.

    - Romans 12:2 – 2 Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect.

    “On one thing I do believe you and I can agree, “God breathed life into you and I.” Set aside all of what biblical supports you rely upon for a moment and consider the enormous suggestion of spiritual intimacy that conveys to how close you are to God right now. There can never be anything, no object, no president, no preacher, no prophet, no action you can do to change the very act of God breathing life into you.”

    Without setting aside Biblical supports I say Amen. Through the Word of God we know what God is about. So do not tempt me to put aside what He deems as valuable.

    2 Timothy 3:16-17 – All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, 17 that the man of God may be competent, equipped for every good work.

    “Now you might think some mistake you may have participated in would make you unworthy of such an intimate gift as the breath of God. But, that thought of lack is unfounded. Why? Because the gift of God’s breath comes to you freely and unconditionally.”

    By who’s and what authority do you say these things? I admit it. I am a mockingbird repeating what I see and hear and believe in Scripture. You do not believe in the Bible. If you did, this would not be coming out of your head. You would not be placing the Bible beneath you like you do. If you believed the Word of Truth, then you would be submitting to it. Instead you are full of pride believing you are great and worthy. We are not worthy… that is why it is called Grace! The Grace of God is undeserved mercy upon wretched sinners. “Amazing Grace how sweet the sound that saved a wretch like me…” You have either never subscribed to Christianity, been saved or have abandoned it all together for some other Gospel and some other Jesus. Repent friend and believe in the One True God and His Son, Jesus the Nazarene, born of a virgin, sinless, crucified for our wretched transgressions which you call mistakes, rose again and now sits at the right hand of the Father. I know where my hope lies… not in myself but in Christ the risen Savior. I decrease so that He may increase…

    “beyond the cross” “If Jesus had not ever come to this world, we would still be blessed by God.”? Christianity is built upon the Atonement. Everything points to the Cross of Jesus at Calvary. Without the Cross of Christ, we would be damned. What are you listening to friend? This is a lie from the pit. Repent and believe in Christ for the forgiveness of sins.

    “The death and resurrection of Jesus only underscores the enormous depth of The Father’s commitment to love us always.”

    Amen to this.

    The death of Christ also underscores the enormous depth of the Father’s hatred of sin.

    You need both messages and both are located in the Cross. The Wrath of God completely absorbed in the Cross and the Love for His people completely illuminated in the Cross.

    Psalm 1
    1:1 Blessed is the man who walks not in the counsel of the wicked, nor stands in the way of sinners, nor sits in the seat of scoffers; 2 but his delight is in the law of the Lord, and on his law he meditates day and night.

    3 He is like a tree planted by streams of water
    that yields its fruit in its season, and its leaf does not wither. In all that he does, he prospers.
    4 The wicked are not so, but are like chaff that the wind drives away. 5 Therefore the wicked will not stand in the judgment, nor sinners in the congregation of the righteous; 6 for the Lord knows the way of the righteous, but the way of the wicked will perish.

  11. “If man is so “great” why do I not see the divorce rate going down, murder going away, steacling, cheating, plundering, etc?”

    The answer to this is simple. If your focus is on failure, in your case “trying to avoid sinning,” then failure is going to be that at which you succeed. It’s like if I told you to not think right now about bananas. The inclination to think of only bananas will happen. So, the same goes with sin. If tell a person don’t sin….then sin is all they have in mind to do. Osteen, then, is encouraging others to think only of living a good life, moving forward toward a place where blessings are real and ready for your use. It is not a matter of JUST thinking good….it is a matter of realizing your good and becoming that for which you yearn.

    The divorce rate actually has subsided in recent years. I believe the percentage of married and divorce is around fifty percent.

    But, let’s say the divorce rate is surging. Why would the divorce rate surge? Why would couples entering into relationships end them as easily as they started them up. There are as many reason as their are couples emerging from families to start new ones.

    To say the divorce rate is surging because they are sinners is too simplistic. And, I know you are far more intellegent than such reasoning. For instance, one person in the relationship may have THOUGHT her choice was Mr Right. After all he fit the mold established by the image of the man she had wanted to marry; a man that was NOT her abusive father. Why then did her choice of a man start to abuse her shortly after they married?

    Those who have abusive childhoods, if they never settle their painful issues within before their marriage, will take all their ugly baggage with them as they enter into abusive relationships. Is it her fault? Is she a sinner for making such a choice? No….she knew only that she wanted to marry a person who was not her father. BUT, she underestimated how influential her father was in teaching her how relationships work. So, she married a person that was like her father because she wanted to now, as an adult, try to CHANGE her father in the man she would marry. So, in her reality she married a ghost, not a man. She is now living a lie. And, a lie is nothing at all, an illusion. Or in her case a nightmare.

    Now, if this same woman is to savor life and live it well–to the fullest, in truth, she needs to recognize the value of the life she has been blessed with by breaking the cycle of her belief system. In your words, she needs to recognize the message of eternal life that Jesus has to offer right now by leaving the relationship to find her real happiness in a life that perhaps is guided by the tenets of Christ. She needs to turn her back on the lie she has chosen to live, walk out of the fog of her illusions, and notice the light of The Father in the name of Jesus waiting to hold her.

    Now in all of these kinds of decisions there is not going to be a cloud at the top of a mountain she will need to climb to get a tablet of rules. BUT, there is going to appear to be a mountain of work she will need to resolve to solve the puzzle of what it means to be happy and to live a good life.

    In all of the same issues you recognize above murder, plundering, scandal, identity theft, cheating, ministers having affairs with gay massage therapists and such it is much the same scenario. All of these person THINK by acting out to kill another, or steal from another, or act inappropriately they will reach a larger sense of happiness. You and I can agree, doing none of these things will bring you to a place of real happiness.

    What will bring you to that place is the two by four experience you have when you notice everyone is truly happy and you are not. At that time you will have a choice continue down a road built on lies and misperceptions or change direction back to where you can see the light and no shadow…GOD. Such is the power of the blessings and gifts you have at present and will always have from The Father who loves you always.

    Thanks for allowing me to share this message with you.

    AngllhugnU2
    IM with God
    http://www.booklocker.com/books/2980.html

  12. “Osteen, then, is encouraging others to think only of living a good life, moving forward toward a place where blessings are real and ready for your use. It is not a matter of JUST thinking good….it is a matter of realizing your good and becoming that for which you yearn.”

    Realizing your good? Jesus said there is no one that is good except God. And Paul said there is no one good (righteous), no not one. Who should I believe? Osteen or the Messiah or the apostles? Oh, I get it. You don’t believe the Bible. Your authority is yourself and Osteen. My authority is God and His Revelation of Himself in Scripture. In it, He, God, says that we are sinners in need of a savior. You and Osteen say we are good and we think poorly about ourselves, so we need to raise our self-esteem. Frankly, I think man esteems himself too much. We need to decrease so that Jesus will increase, just as John the Baptist, the greatest prophet ever, according to Jesus, did. Read The Gospel according to Matthew.

    “The divorce rate actually has subsided in recent years. I believe the percentage of married and divorce is around fifty percent.”

    50% in the world, 51% and rising in the Church. Tell me. Is Osteen’s message, which is not the first, but has been around for more than 45 years… is it working? Are people being changed or are they being pamphered. This cotton-candy Christianity has to stop. Tell me real doctrine from the Holy Book. Tell me the mind of God found int he pages of Holy Writ, the Bible. Do not tell me the latest fad or the latest pop-psychology that makes God look like the Big Santa Clause or Water Boy in the sky waiting to simply give you whatever you demand or want. This is foolishness.

    “But, let’s say the divorce rate is surging. Why would the divorce rate surge? Why would couples entering into relationships end them as easily as they started them up. There are as many reason as their are couples emerging from families to start new ones.”

    Jesus comments: They said to him, “Why then did Moses command one to give a certificate of divorce and to send her away?” 8 He said to them, “Because of your hardness of heart Moses allowed you to divorce your wives, but from the beginning it was not so. 9 And I say to you: whoever divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality, and marries another, commits adultery.” (Matthew 19:7-9)

    “Now, if this same woman is to savor life and live it well–to the fullest, in truth, she needs to recognize the value of the life she has been blessed with by breaking the cycle of her belief system. In your words, she needs to recognize the message of eternal life that Jesus has to offer right now by leaving the relationship to find her real happiness in a life that perhaps is guided by the tenets of Christ. She needs to turn her back on the lie she has chosen to live, walk out of the fog of her illusions, and notice the light of The Father in the name of Jesus waiting to hold her.”

    If you say this to anyone you are a liar. God has not promised happiness. He promises covenant which means commitment. We become harlots all the time when we sin, and yet God even in His grief over our sin against Him never divorces us. Your happiness is not found in marriage, material things, church, anything… Happiness is found in faithfulness to Christ Jesus. Blessed are those who suffer. Blessed are those who mourn. Blessed are the poor in spirit. Blessed are those who are persecuted. All of these things do not compare to the things you say. They are deeper than superficiality. They say to a person who has Cancer… You are blessed because you suffer and still Glorify God. They say to the mother who lost her child to a disease… You are blessed because you love Jesus in spite of your loss. It says to a wife who has an abusive husband… You are blessed because you have stayed in the marriage for it reflects Christ and His own Bride, the Church, who He bought with His blood.

    “What will bring you to that place is the two by four experience you have when you notice everyone is truly happy and you are not. At that time you will have a choice continue down a road built on lies and misperceptions or change direction back to where you can see the light and no shadow…GOD. Such is the power of the blessings and gifts you have at present and will always have from The Father who loves you always.”

    Champ, I am very content and happy. I have Christ as Savior and a citizenship in Heaven that cannot be taken away. Nothing can separate me from the love of Christ. (Romans 8)

    What I do have is conviction. You may see this as unhappiness… I see it as mission for God. We are to go into the world baptizing people in the name fo the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit and teaching them to follow Christ’s commandments. What you are is decieved by Mr. Osteen’s message.

    Where is God found? Everywhere. What is the mind of God? A mystery… but He has given us information in the inspired, infallible, inerrant Word of Truth known as the Bible. In it you will find what and who you truly are and Who God truly is. Mr. Osteen raises this up and makes statements that says “I am what it says I am and have what it says I have…” But does He ever open it and read it to the congregation? No he does not. I suggest you and he should open it and read it. (In context)

    Friend do not take my word for it. Take Christ’s Word for it. Read the Gospels and the rest of the New Testament. Find out for yourself. Stop relying on teachers who may or may not know what they are talking about regarding God. Do not be your own authority, but rely on God and His Word for your authority. It seems you don’t think the Bible is sufficient enough or it is archaic or something. I say, put all of those misconceptions aside and go to the real source of truth, God’s Divine Relevation of Himself found in the pages of Scripture.

    Blessed In Christ’s Teachings and Commands,
    RAP

  13. “God has not promised happiness.” Herein lies the struggle some have with why there is so much unhappiness, war, struggle, confusion, depression, and lack of remorse.

    You will note I have not one time said in all of what I have written, “you’re wrong!” Why? I can not judge at what point you will yourself to touch what is great within you. Perhaps, right now it maybe in the familiarity and confidence you have in being (as you assert) a “mockingbird” of scripture. And, that is okay.

    The spiritual journey you are on is the same upon which all travel. The discoveries, great and small, you will make in the near future about how much of God’s goodness and greatness is inbed deep within you will catch you off guard. And, at those times you will praise God for having blessed you so. At that time your attacks upon another will slowly cease and you will will yourself to embrace your wholeness.

    I am always impressed with those who contentment comes from the body of work of those whose choice to express their relationship with God in the scriptures. It is a good sign that true leaders lead well beyond their bodies pass into the dust beneath our feet. Such is the meaning of eternity…The One (God’s) word wills to express Love always….And, at present right now you are the embodiment of some body who seeks to follow the path of truth as it has been laid before you so that you too will know eternal life.

    Congratulations!

    AngllHugnU2
    Author of IM with God
    http://www.booklocker.com/books/2980.html

  14. “God has not promised happiness.” Herein lies the struggle some have with why there is so much unhappiness, war, struggle, confusion, depression, and lack of remorse.

    You took my statement out of context. I added to this statement, God has promised covenant. When we are in covenant with God and others, even when it is bad or we are sick or are diseased, we are truly at peace and content with life as it comes. This is not a mediocre way of looking at life. It is looking at life the way things are. When your struggle comes, you are not particularly happy about it, but when you know you are in God’s will you are content with anything that comes. Contentment and happiness are two different things. I can be content and not necessarily thrilled about what I am going through. James says to count it pure joy when we endure trials of many kinds knowing that it will produce in us character and maturity. When we look at it this way we can be happy with the coming result of our trials, not necessarily our situation. If you mean by happy, joyful, then I will go with that. But even when you don’t necessarily feel joyful, you can still be blessed knowing that you are in Christ the Lord. Friend, the only way to know true joy, contentment, happiness is to be in the Father. And the only way to be in the Father is to have His Son Jesus as your Savior. And what does Jesus save us from: Sin, Death, and Hell… Moreover, He saves us from ourselves. We are, according to King Jesus’ words, to carry a Cross. The Cross is not some symbol we look to, but an instrument of death. We are, as Paul says, to die daily to ourselves and in return benefit the Kingdom.

    “You will note I have not one time said in all of what I have written, “you’re wrong!” Why? I can not judge at what point you will yourself to touch what is great within you. Perhaps, right now it maybe in the familiarity and confidence you have in being (as you assert) a “mockingbird” of scripture. And, that is okay.”

    I will say that you are wrong. I have no problem with saying it. There are absolutes and there is only One Truth, that being that Christ came and died for sinners like you and me. And when we repent and believe in Him we have eternal life. If we refuse to do so, we end up in Hell and suffer the wrath of God. You see God as loving devoid of justice. When you do not have a just God, you have an unloving God. God is both Gracious and Just… He balances perfectly both His wrath and His grace. When we are too far on either side we do not represent Him accurately. My friend, He is loving but also wrathful. And if all we get is the loving side of God without the demand for repentance, then we deceive ourselves and end up finding out the hard way that God does not know us. We need Jesus so that we can be made righteous, perfect, holy… it is not within ourselves to do so. My authroity rests in Scripture alone. The Reformation brought this out: Sola Scriptura, Sola Fide, Soli Gratia, Solus Christus… Only Scripture, Only Faith, Only Grace, Only Christ… You need Faith in Christ to be saved and faith comes from God’s Grace. We find this out in Scripture. My confidence is not in myself, but in the Grace of our Lord Christ. When you look to him, you will find peace and grace and true contentment… a love that will never fail. There is nothing great in you sir… only Jesus if He is in you. The only reason God can look at us, is because the blood of Christ is on us… if indeed it is on you. I persuade you please to not forsake the Truth of God’s Word for easy believism or cheap grace.

    “The spiritual journey you are on is the same upon which all travel.”

    Wrong. Only a few find the road that leads to God’s abode. Jesus, the God of the Universe, says that broad is the way to destruction and narrow is the way that leads to life and FEW that find it. Friend, do not be deceived. Muslims, Buddhists, Atheists, Hindus, Agnostics, unbelieving baptists, presbyterians, catholic, and methodists will go to Hell if they do not repent of their sins and believe in Christ, the One Savior of Mankind. If they reject God’s Son, the God rejects them. This is plain in Scripture. You first need to see Scripture as truth, absloutely and totally, before you will be able to accept these words. Then, you will see the lies that come from prosperity, health and wealth, teachers/preachers.

    “At that time your attacks upon another will slowly cease and you will will yourself to embrace your wholeness.”

    Who says I am attacking. You may feel attacked, but that is not my intention. My intention is to critically think about what you are saying and what Mr. Osteen and others say in regard to Scripture. Is it accurate? Does it pass the test of God? It does not pass this test. I do not attack you friend… that is what the Devil does… Everything I have spoken thus far has been in love. If I let you continue down this road without saying anything regarding the falseness of the claims you are holding to, then I would be unloving. The loving thing to do is to guide people into the truth of God’s Word seeing that Christ is our treasure, not OUR happiness or OUR success, or OUR prosperity or OUR self-esteem, or OUR whatever… This is a very selfish way at looking at God… He become Santa Clause or our Waterboy more than the Creator and Sustainer of the Heavens and the Earth.

    By the way… I feel whole… I haev Jesus as my Lord living within me. I have been saved, Saved, SAVED! Amen! You cannot feel anymore whole than that.

    Believe in Jesus. Repent of Sin. Walk with God in Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit.

    In Him, RAP

  15. This has been great fun. I’m glad we agree on some many things. Have a great day! :-)

    AngllHugnU2
    Author of IM with God
    http://www.booklocker.com/books/2980.html

Leave a Reply